Dancing with Broken Bones · Study 2 of 7 · Psalm 51:3–5
It is one thing to say, “I wish I had never done that.” It is another to say why. Perhaps we wish the memory would leave us alone. Perhaps we miss someone’s trust. Both losses can bring us to tears. David’s confession leads him to a harder question. If no one had ever found out, what would still have been wrong with what he did?
When the matter is still before us
Read Psalm 51:3 alongside Psalm 32:3–5. In one prayer David knows his transgression and can see it continually. In the other he remembers the weariness of keeping silent. Silence takes work. Once we have given a misleading account, we have to remember which version we told to whom. Even an ordinary question can begin to sound like a threat.
Consider the people caught up in David’s concealment in 2 Samuel 11. Uriah carried a letter that arranged his own death. Joab received the order and acted on it. Bathsheba mourned her husband. When the king eventually spoke to Nathan, he could acknowledge his guilt in a single sentence (2 Samuel 12:13). The brevity of the confession does nothing to diminish the weight of what he confessed.
Why David says he has sinned against God
The word only in verse 4 ought to slow us down. How can David address God this way when Uriah is dead? Listen to the charge Nathan brought. God had given David the kingdom and delivered him from Saul. David despised the Lord’s word when he took Uriah’s wife and had Uriah killed (2 Samuel 12:7–10). The very acts that devastated this household expressed contempt for the God who had entrusted David with authority.
That gives our prayers a searching test. Suppose I humiliate a student in front of a class. I can acknowledge the wrong to God that evening. The next morning there is still a student whose dignity I treated lightly. Indeed, it is precisely because that student matters to God that I should seek the student out, listen, and take responsibility for what I said.
The root goes deeper than the deed
I once had a tree in Torrance that was easier to cut down than to get out by the roots. Verse 5 takes us below the part of David’s life everyone could see. He traces his need for mercy all the way to the beginning of his life. He accepts God’s verdict in verse 4 and then confesses how far down the trouble goes. Appealing to a lifelong tendency as an excuse would undo the very confession he is making.
Consider a pattern you recognize in yourself. When you interrupt someone to get the last word, what seems so important to protect? When you let a false impression stand because it favors you, whose approval are you afraid to lose? Stay with one question long enough to answer it honestly. First John 1:9 gives us reason to do that. God is faithful to forgive and cleanse those who confess their sins.
Bring the whole matter to God
In your own words, finish these two sentences in prayer. “Lord, what I did was …” and “What I wanted badly enough to do it was …” Then consider whether someone is owed a correction, an apology, or restitution. A trusted believer can pray with you and ask you later how that conversation went (Galatians 6:1–2).
Father, You know what I have done and what I wanted when I did it. Help me agree with You about both. Thank You for meeting me with mercy in Christ. Give me humility to make right what is in my power to repair. Amen.
Adapted from David R. Williamson’s sermon “The Confession of Completion” (February 6, 1994). Series title drawn from D. Swartz, Dancing with Broken Bones (NavPress, 1987).
Previous study · The Nature of Sin
Next study · Snap! Crackle! Pop!
View all seven Psalm 51 studies
1 thought on “The Confession of Completion”