I’m Broken, Now What?

Dancing with Broken Bones · Study 7 of 7 · Psalm 51:15–17

Who taught you how to receive correction? A teacher may have explained it to you. You may remember more clearly the day a teacher stood before a class, acknowledged a mistake, and made it right. Students who witness that moment learn something that would be hard to put on an exam. They see what humility asks of the person who holds the authority.

As we come to the last message in this series, read Psalm 51:15–17. David has asked the Lord to open his lips in praise. He now considers what he might bring before God. A king has the means to make an impressive offering. What does a king bring when the very heart from which he gives is what needs God’s attention?

The sacrifice God receives

In verse 16 David imagines giving a sacrifice and knows that an offering alone cannot answer for what he has done. He cannot restore Uriah’s life or undo the orders he issued. Bringing a costly animal would still leave him with the question Nathan exposed. Will he bow to God’s judgment about the way he used his power?

Read verse 17, and then read ahead to verse 19. By the end of the psalm David can envision sacrifices offered rightly. A broken and contrite heart makes sense of that sequence. The worshiper comes with empty hands, willing to let God tell the truth and willing to receive what God gives. Then praise and the outward acts of worship can express what is true within. Notice the promise that makes it possible to come at all. God will receive the very heart that its owner might be ashamed to bring.

A teachable heart on an ordinary day

Suppose a young person tells you, “I stopped answering questions because you laughed at my answer.” An adult may recall the occasion quite differently. It is tempting to begin with what we meant. A teachable response makes room for another sentence from the student. “I remember laughing. I didn’t realize what that was like for you. Will you tell me more?” The conversation may uncover a wrong we need to put right. It may also show us something about how we use humor every week.

James 1:21–25 connects receiving the Word with doing what it says. Read a passage, turn it into a prayer, and ask what obedience requires in the next ordinary encounter. A teacher can return to the student. A parent can keep a promise made in an apology. A church leader can invite someone who spoke honestly to tell them, a month later, whether anything has changed.

The example someone else will follow

In Luke 22:31–32 Jesus speaks to Peter about both his coming failure and his responsibility afterward. When Peter has turned back, he is to strengthen his brothers. Later, on the shore, the risen Jesus entrusts him with the care of His sheep (John 21:15–17). Peter has something to do with the mercy he has received. People who need care can now receive it from a man who knows what it was to need mercy himself.

Whom do you look to when obedience is difficult? What do they do that helps you follow Christ? Now turn the question around. Who can see your life closely enough to learn from the way you respond when you are wrong? Ask God to bring one person to mind. Consider one act of patience, forgiveness, or service that person could actually experience from you this week (Ephesians 4:32).

Returning to the beginning

Read the psalm once more, from its opening appeal for mercy to its closing prayer for Zion. David began with a deeply personal wrong. By the end he can pray for the good of the community. That gives us somewhere to go as we close this series. Bring your own need honestly before the Lord. Then pray by name for people whose good you have the opportunity to seek.

Father, thank You for receiving a contrite heart. Keep me teachable when someone sees a fault I have missed. May the people who know me best experience something of the patience and mercy You have shown me in Jesus. Amen.

Adapted from David R. Williamson’s sermon “I’m Broken, Now What?” (March 13, 1994). Series title drawn from D. Swartz, Dancing with Broken Bones (NavPress, 1987).

Previous study · The Audience Is Listening
View all seven Psalm 51 studies

Leave a Comment