Dancing with Broken Bones · Study 1 of 7 · Psalm 51:1–2
Have you ever rehearsed an apology and spent most of the time deciding how to explain yourself? By the time we have described the pressure we were under and what the other person did first, it can be hard to hear what we are asking forgiveness for. We want to grow in godliness, yet even a simple apology can show us what we are reluctant to give up. Are we willing to let the person we hurt hear the whole truth, even if it costs us their good opinion? Listen to the first words of David’s prayer: “Have mercy on me, O God” (Psalm 51:1, KJV). He has come to the end of his explanations. What gives him the courage to speak at all?
When Nathan came to David
The heading of Psalm 51 takes us back to a visit from the prophet Nathan. David had taken Bathsheba, the wife of Uriah. When she became pregnant, David arranged for Uriah to be abandoned in battle and killed. He then took Bathsheba into his house. To someone watching from a distance, the matter might have appeared settled. Second Samuel 11 closes by telling us how the Lord regarded what David had done.
Nathan told the king about a rich man who took a poor man’s one beloved ewe lamb to feed a guest. David could see the cruelty plainly when he thought he was judging another man. Then Nathan identified the man in the story. Read David’s answer in 2 Samuel 12:13. The king who had issued orders and moved men around to conceal his guilt finally spoke for himself. He had sinned against the Lord. Uriah’s death and the wrong done to Bathsheba give those words their terrible weight.
Three ways David names his sin
Read Psalm 51:1–2 slowly. David calls what he has done transgression, iniquity, and sin. The words overlap. Together they help us hear how fully he owns what he did. Notice the small word that accompanies each one: my.
Transgression. David had crossed a boundary the Lord had given him. He knew whose wife Bathsheba was. Each subsequent order gave him another occasion to turn back. Psalm 19:13 gives us a prayer for the moment when we know what God requires and still want our own way. We can ask the Lord for help then, even with the order unwritten or the hurtful words still unspoken.
Iniquity. Consider what happened to David’s judgment. Uriah’s loyalty should have been a cause for gratitude. Instead, David came to see that loyalty as an obstacle to his plans (2 Samuel 11:6–15). We ought to pay attention when our reasons for doing something grow more elaborate while the person who stands to be hurt all but disappears from our thinking.
Sin. We fall short of the glory of God (Romans 3:23). One of the easiest ways to evade that truth is to choose someone with whom we compare favorably. David had already found such a man in Nathan’s story. His indignation came readily. Confession came when he let God’s word address him. Whose faults come most readily to mind when you know the Lord is dealing with one of yours?
What David asks God to do
Go back through the verses and listen for the verbs. Blot out. Wash. Cleanse. To blot something out is to remove what stands on the record. David could have a letter delivered to a commander. He could never write another letter that would bring Uriah home. He must ask God to forgive what he cannot undo. Psalm 32:1 describes the blessedness of the person whose transgression the Lord has forgiven.
Then the image changes. Anyone who has tried to wash a stain from a garment understands why David asks to be washed thoroughly. He has lived with this sin long enough to know how deeply it has worked its way into his decisions. In asking God to cleanse him, he brings himself, as well as his deeds, before the Lord.
The ground for all three requests is already there in verse 1. David appeals to God’s steadfast love and abundant mercy. Christians see the cost of that mercy in Jesus Christ. Isaiah 53:5–6 speaks of the servant wounded for our transgressions. Ephesians 2:4–5 tells us that God, rich in mercy, made us alive with Christ while we were dead in our sins. We can tell the truth to the God who has loved us at such a cost.
Praying these verses ourselves
Bring one particular wrong before the Lord. Perhaps you spoke harshly to someone at home and later described yourself as “just tired.” Begin with the words you actually spoke. Ask God to forgive you. Then consider what the person who heard them needs from you. An honest apology might be as short as this: “What I said to you was cruel. Will you forgive me?” Give the other person room to answer.
There is a reason a series on repentance can carry a title about dancing. A little further into the psalm, David asks that the bones God has broken might rejoice (verse 8). Even here, in the opening plea, we can hear the beginning of that hope. David knows whom he is asking for mercy.
Father, show me where I have defended what I ought to confess. Give me courage to name the wrong I have done and humility to hear the person I have hurt. Thank You for the mercy You have shown me in Christ. Teach me to walk today in the light of that mercy. Amen.
Adapted from David R. Williamson’s sermon “The Nature of Sin,” preached January 30, 1994. The archived sermon bibliography credits D. Swartz, Dancing with Broken Bones: Blessed Are the Broken in Spirit, for God Can Make Them Whole (NavPress, 1987), the source of the series title.
Next study · The Confession of Completion
View all seven Psalm 51 studies
2 thoughts on “The Nature of Sin”