By David R. Williamson
Adapted from an assignment written February 15, 2009, for EDU313, Educational Psychology, at Grand Canyon University. The original explored task analysis through lessons on two-digit addition and jumping rope. This revised article develops that practical approach for classroom and ministry teaching.
A task that seems simple to an experienced teacher may contain several unfamiliar steps for a learner. We may explain the whole process, demonstrate it once, and then wonder why a student cannot begin. The difficulty may lie in a step we perform so readily that we no longer think to explain it.
Task analysis asks us to examine the work closely: What must the learner know and do? Which parts depend on earlier understanding? Where might the learner need instruction or practice? The purpose is to make a path into the task clear while keeping its larger meaning in view.
Begin with the intended learning
Before dividing a task into steps, describe what successful learning should look like. “Complete the worksheet” identifies an activity. “Add two-digit numbers and explain how place value affects the calculation” identifies something we can examine in the student’s understanding.
The goal helps determine what to teach and what to assess. If students are learning to explain their reasoning, correct answers alone will not tell us everything we need to know. Ask them to show or describe how they reached the answer.
The same question matters in a Bible class. A completed study guide may show that students found words in a passage. If the goal is understanding, ask them to explain the author’s point and support their explanation from the text. Decide what you are seeking before choosing the activity.
Check what the learner already knows
The original paper noted that some steps could be omitted because the learner already knew them. That decision should follow observation rather than assumption. Ask a question, offer a short task, or have the student demonstrate the prerequisite skill.
Before teaching two-digit addition, check whether students can add single-digit numbers and explain tens and ones. A student who can recite addition facts may still need help understanding place value. Knowing that distinction gives the teacher a more useful starting point.
Avoid spending the whole lesson rehearsing what students can already do, but be ready to return to a missing foundation. The sequence should serve the learners before you rather than simply follow the plan used with a previous class.
Identify the steps and their connections
Work through the task yourself and name what you are doing. Consider both visible actions and decisions that may otherwise remain hidden. A student may copy the arrangement of numbers correctly without understanding why the columns matter.
For example, adding 12 and 14 can be taught by identifying the tens and ones in each number, aligning the place values, combining the ones, combining the tens, and interpreting the result as 26. Explain the relationship between each written digit and the quantity it represents.
When the lesson moves to regrouping, the sequence must include that new idea. In 27 + 18, the ones combine to make 15 ones. Ten of those ones form another ten, leaving 5 ones. The 2 tens, 1 ten, and additional ten make 4 tens, giving a total of 45. Merely telling students to write a small number above the next column leaves the meaning unexplained.
Choose the size of each step according to the learner’s needs. Some students may work through several parts together; others need a closer look at one part. A useful plan allows that adjustment.
Demonstrate with enough explanation
A demonstration should make the process understandable. Show what you do, explain why you do it, and allow students to ask questions. Give attention to the point at which the task may become confusing.
The jump-rope lesson in the original paper illustrates this concern. The account describes revising the sequence when the learner did not understand the rope’s movement. The reflection was that the order of explanation mattered and needed adjustment for that learner.
In preparing such a demonstration, you could distinguish holding the rope, moving it over the body, and coordinating the jump as it approaches the feet. Observe which part needs practice rather than simply repeating the instruction to jump. Adapt the activity to the learner’s ability and the teaching setting.
A physical demonstration and a mathematical explanation require different forms of attention. Both call for a teacher who knows the task well enough to notice where the learner’s attempt differs from the intended process.
Practice together and give specific feedback
After demonstrating, provide an opportunity for students to try the task with help available. Ask them to explain what they are doing. Their words and actions can show whether a difficulty concerns the instructions, an underlying concept, or the coordination of several steps.
Feedback should identify the point that needs attention. In addition, “Check which column contains the ones” gives a student a place to look. “Wrong—try again” offers little direction. Once the student finds the error, ask for an explanation and another attempt.
When the learner can complete a part successfully, connect it with the next part. Keep returning to the whole task so students understand why the smaller steps belong together. Following a sequence without understanding its purpose can conceal confusion.
Check independence and understanding
An answer produced while the teacher supplies every prompt does not show what the student can do alone. After supported practice, offer a suitable opportunity to complete the task without those prompts. Attend to both the result and the process.
For the addition lesson, ask students to solve another problem and explain a choice they made. If regrouping is the objective, include a problem that actually requires it. The assessment should match the learning you intended to teach.
Revisit the skill later and consider whether students can use it in a related situation. If they struggle, examine where support is still needed. A successful first attempt is encouraging, but it does not answer every question about continuing understanding.
Apply the approach to Bible teaching
A teacher might tell students to “apply this passage” without explaining the work involved. A useful sequence could begin with reading the passage in context, identifying its main point, explaining what it teaches, and considering a response consistent with that meaning. Model the process before expecting students to carry it out independently.
First John 3:16–18 offers an example. Begin by examining how John connects Christ’s sacrifice with love for fellow believers. Ask students to explain the concern about seeing someone in need while withholding help. Then invite them to consider a suitable act of care in light of what the passage teaches.
This sequence serves careful reading and thoughtful response. It should not become a formula that promises spiritual maturity when every box is checked. Teachers can explain, model, encourage, and provide opportunities for practice; inward renewal remains God’s work (Titus 3:4–7).
Revise the lesson in light of the learner
The original assignment reported a positive result with one child and recognized that teaching a larger group could require changes. That is a useful limit to retain. One experience can help us examine our planning without establishing that the same sequence will work equally well for every learner.
After a lesson, consider where students proceeded independently and where they needed repeated help. Did you omit a prerequisite? Was a term unfamiliar? Did the demonstration move too quickly? Did the final task actually assess the intended learning?
Record one adjustment before teaching the lesson again. Our responsibility includes knowing the subject, attending to the student, and being willing to change an explanation. Examining the steps can help us replace a vague impression of difficulty with something we can teach more carefully.
Questions for reflection
What task do you regularly assign without explaining the steps a beginner may need?
How will you check the learner’s prerequisite knowledge before teaching it?
Which part of your demonstration needs a clearer explanation of why it matters?
What will show that students can complete the task independently and understand what they are doing?
Original paper and source background
This article substantially adapts David R. Williamson’s EDU313 Module Six Assignment, dated February 15, 2009. The original included a discussion of learning theories, task analysis, lesson plans, scripted instruction, and a reflection on teaching two-digit addition and jumping rope. The regrouping explanation and Bible-teaching example here develop the original approach rather than reproduce its lesson scripts.
The original paper drew on David H. Jonassen, Martin Tessmer, and Wallace H. Hannum’s Task Analysis Methods for Instructional Design (Lawrence Erlbaum Associates, 1999), including its discussion of identifying and sequencing tasks. This article paraphrases the supplied paper’s practical approach without reproducing the book’s lists or offering a comprehensive account of its methods.
Other sources in the original bibliography included J. E. Ormrod’s Educational Psychology: Developing Learners (6th ed., Pearson, 2008); J. Johnson and colleagues’ Foundations of American Education: Perspectives on Education in a Changing World (14th ed., Pearson, 2008); and A. C. Ornstein and D. U. Levine’s Foundations of Education (10th ed., Houghton Mifflin, 2008). These are identified as the original paper’s source background rather than newly verified support for every suggestion in this adaptation.
The original appendices also cited Arizona curriculum standards and additional instructional resources. Those historical standards and links are not presented here as current curriculum requirements.